Difference between revisions of "Talk:Don't Rule/Archive 1"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(Created page with "I'm sorry, but Ithis rule sounds like a singularly Bad Idea. The odds of a player saying "don't X" and meaning just that (in- or off-character) rather than "please do more of ...") |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | I'm sorry, but Ithis rule sounds like a singularly Bad Idea. The odds of a player saying "don't X" and meaning just that (in- or off-character) rather than "please do more of X" are overwhelmingly high. Rules such as this are also easily abused (or perceived to be abused) by "strong" players trying to push others into playing beyond their comfort level, as we found when we tried a similar rule in Oslo in the late 90s. Where does the rule come from? Has it been extensively play-tested? | + | I'm sorry, but Ithis rule sounds like a singularly Bad Idea. The odds of a player saying "don't X" and meaning just that (in- or off-character) rather than "please do more of X" are overwhelmingly high. Rules such as this are also easily abused (or perceived to be abused) by "strong" players trying to push others into playing beyond their comfort level, as we found when we tried a similar rule in Oslo in the late 90s. Where does the rule come from? Has it been extensively play-tested? Is this common practice in some larp tradition? --[[User:Efatland|Efatland]] 19:05, 23 April 2012 (CEST) |
Revision as of 18:05, 23 April 2012
I'm sorry, but Ithis rule sounds like a singularly Bad Idea. The odds of a player saying "don't X" and meaning just that (in- or off-character) rather than "please do more of X" are overwhelmingly high. Rules such as this are also easily abused (or perceived to be abused) by "strong" players trying to push others into playing beyond their comfort level, as we found when we tried a similar rule in Oslo in the late 90s. Where does the rule come from? Has it been extensively play-tested? Is this common practice in some larp tradition? --Efatland 19:05, 23 April 2012 (CEST)
